Letter to Ha’aretz Newspaper

Catherine Buntin is CAPA’s President.

From an American Nurse

We have done everything possible to protest our government sending weapons to Israel to no avail.

The only hope for stopping this genocidal war sits in your hands, the people of Israel.  You can organize to say “Not in our Name” to Netanyahu and your extremist right wing government. 

So far, the only protests in Israel have been organized around the remaining Israeli hostages.  While that may be understandable, it is not the whole story while over 2,000 innocent Palestinians languish in your tortuous prisons.  They too are hostages, and they are voiceless.

The Jewish faith does not condone ethnic cleansing.  Your care and your voice must bring down this government which would annihilate another people.  Hamas has said it fights to end the occupation, for their people to be free. They will not lay down their arms any more than Israel would lay down its arms.  This appears to be a war of racist intent, one of white superiority. A war of power over the powerless and for a major land grab.

Killing civilians is a war crime, be it 120 innocent or 50,000 innocents.  Hamas was wrong and what Israel has done is unconscionable.

Netanyahu does not intend to ever allow a two-state solution.  He has demonstrated his intention of stealing land from several of your neighbors, including Lebanon and Syria, and Gaza and the West Bank, to create the “Greater Israel”.  He is proud to show his new map of the future.  I must ask, do you condone this? 

He has also demonstrated that he will execute, at will, any leaders in other countries. Is this the world we want to live in– a lawless world where tyrants can take you out with drones from the sky, while you sleep?

The slaughter in Gaza is inhumane and the Israeli soldiers who have killed and maimed these people will live out their lives with deep emotional and spiritual scars. And how will the world see Israelis from now on?  Will they care about your history, your pain, your suffering?  Hardly. You have no moral ground to stand on now and neither do we, we who have supplied your bombs.

There are starving people next door to you.  I weep—even want to scream—for the beautiful children starving and dying a painful death.  And for their parents. Please care enough to bring down your government–  You can stop this war.

M. Catherine Buntin, RN, MS, MPH

GAZA, HAMAS, OCCUPATION, LET’S ASK MORE QUESTIONS….

by Catherine Buntin, August 2024

Americans have protested the genocide in Gaza for these past 10 months. It has been anguishing to see the daily terror and murder of the Palestinian families and children. It’s a barbaric war.

Reflecting on my participation in the street protests at the Democratic convention last week, and having conversations with people from across the country who care deeply about a peace in the middle east, several themes emerged from these discussions that are shared here.

MANY THINGS ABOUT THIS WAR ARE CLEAR TO EVERYONE.

No one excuses the horrific murders of October 7th.  It is a war crime to kill civilians. But proportionality has been lost, the response is openly intended as genocide.

Hamas is a military force, but it also has provided government services to the Palestinian people in Gaza, much as the militant Black Panthers in Chicago also provided basic needed services to their communities for years (something that went unrecognized). These entities serve as more than one thing for their people. 

The occupation has meant that Palestinians have no control over their economy, over their power sources and water resources.  No control over the food supplies or travel out of their region.  And no opportunity for a defense force, or a military base, thus the tunnels their only way to resist occupation. Moreover, Israeli settler violence against Palestinians that happens daily, long has been met with immunity.

Many freedoms are out of reach for Palestinians.  Home security versus home demolitions, secure streets versus IDF snatching and taking people prisoners at whim. A secure environment for children versus abuse of children on the streets and in their homes.  Israelis hold Prisoners like hostages for years often without charges or on fabricated charges.

KNOWING ALL THIS, WE MUST ASK SOME CRITICAL QUESTIONS OF OURSELVES, if we proclaim to hold the moral high ground as often, we do.

Do Palestinians have the same right to defend themselves as Israel has to defend itself?

Is it natural to resist an oppressor? If so, does that resister deserve to be called a terrorist?

What about the oppressors?  Should they be defined as terrorists?

Is “occupation” a racist system of oppression?  Is one side deserving of freedom and security at the expense of the other?  Or are both peoples born with the inalienable rights of freedom and liberty? 

Bringing the questions home, how can Americans convince their politicians to withhold further support from the oppressor in order to achieve a permanent ceasefire and an end to Israel’s genocidal goals?

Finally, do Palestinian citizens have the right to decide the role Hamas should play in their future government just as Israeli citizens are allowed to decide whether Netanyahu will be their leader for tomorrow?

If we ask these questions with an open mind, will we be better prepared to work for a realistic (or an actual) peace in the Middle East?

Catherine Buntin, Public Health Nurse and Board Member, Chicago Area Peace Action

09.22.19

40th ANNUAL